Exercise Physiology Institute

Strategies for Effective Behaviour Change in Physical Activity Intervention

Encouraging individuals to adopt and maintain long-term physical activity (PA) behaviors can be challenging. Studies have shown that while PA levels may increase during intervention phases, they often decline significantly after the cessation of the intervention. This article explores the complexity of behavior change in PA interventions and the importance of adherence to PA guidelines. It also discusses the use of behavior change techniques (BCTs) and frameworks to design and implement effective interventions.

Challenges in Maintaining Physical Activity Behaviour

A meta-analysis of interventions aimed at maintaining PA behavior found that, despite initial increases in PA during the intervention phase, adherence to PA guidelines decreased significantly in the long term. This pattern was observed in studies involving both adult participants and older adults. Similar results were found in interventions targeting the cancer population, where PA levels returned to baseline following completion of supervised sessions. These findings emphasize the need for strategies to promote long-term adherence to PA guidelines and interventions.

The Importance of Adherence to Physical Activity

Adherence to PA is crucial for various populations, including individuals with cancer. Treatment outcomes, quality of life, and physical decline are closely tied to compliance with PA interventions in this population. Poor adherence has been linked to factors such as exercise intolerance, limited knowledge and experience, lack of social and professional support, and the absence of individually-tailored exercise prescriptions. To improve adherence, interventions have been developed, including telephone support, peer support, and the integration of technology and devices.

Individualized Approaches and Behaviour Change Strategies

Successful exercise interventions require a client-centered approach and individually tailored strategies. It is essential to combine evidence-based exercise prescriptions with behavior change strategies to achieve the desired health-related outcomes. Various behavior change theories and frameworks, such as social cognitive theory and theory of planned behavior, have been implemented in PA interventions. However, these theories may not cover the full range of influences on behavior. The Behavior Change Wheel (BCW) provides a comprehensive framework that synthesizes 19 behavior change frameworks and uses a common language to describe behavior change techniques (BCTs).

Identifying Behaviour Change Techniques

The BCW, supported by the Behavior Change Technique Taxonomy (BCTT), allows researchers and practitioners to design and select behavior change strategies based on a thorough analysis of the target behavior and population. This systematic framework facilitates a clearer understanding of the active components of an intervention and their individual or combined effects. It enables the identification of specific BCTs used in interventions, which enhances replication, synthesis, and the development of evidence-based interventions.

Commonly Used Behaviour Change Techniques

Several systematic reviews have identified commonly used BCTs in PA interventions across different populations. These include goal setting, social support, feedback and monitoring, demonstration of behavior, self-monitoring, and graded tasks. Combining multiple BCTs in interventions has been associated with higher rates of adoption and adherence to health behaviors. However, there is a lack of empirically based recommendations regarding the optimal method, dose, and fidelity of delivering BCTs to elicit PA behavior change.

Enhancing Intervention Reporting and Replication

The Template for Intervention Description and Replication (TIDieR) checklist addresses the inadequate or incomplete reporting of intervention descriptions. It provides a systematic way to describe interventions, including delivery context, intensity, duration, and fidelity assessment. By integrating the BCTT and the TIDieR checklist, researchers and practitioners can enhance intervention development, implementation, and reporting, thus facilitating future program development and creating a common language.

Encouraging and maintaining long-term PA behavior change is a complex process. Adherence to PA guidelines and interventions is crucial for achieving positive health outcomes. By utilizing behavior change theories, frameworks, and techniques, along with comprehensive reporting, researchers and practitioners can design and implement.

Scroll to Top